Quick answerRestraint of trade clauses in a business sale are enforceable only if they are no wider than reasonably necessary to protect the goodwill acquired. In DXC Eclipse and GBAR v Brown, the restraints were too broad or did not bind the key individual. Queensland courts cannot rewrite an unreasonable restraint, so careful drafting matters.
Last reviewed: 3 November 2026
When purchasing an established business, the purchase price often reflects more than the value of its physical assets.
A significant part of the price may relate to goodwill, including the business’s reputation and its established customer relationships.
For this reason, business purchase agreements commonly contain restraint of trade provisions designed to prevent the seller from establishing or becoming involved in a competing business after completion.
However, these provisions are not automatically enforceable simply because both parties have agreed to them.
The decisions in DXC Eclipse Pty Ltd v Wildsmith [2023] NSWCA 98 and GBAR (Australia) Pty Ltd v Brown [2020] QSC 14 demonstrate the importance of carefully drafted restraint provisions and ensuring that they are no wider than reasonably necessary to protect the goodwill being acquired.
Background to the DXC Eclipse Dispute
In 2018, DXC Eclipse Pty Ltd acquired Sable37, a business specialising in Microsoft software solutions.
The acquisition was undertaken through a securities purchase agreement involving several sellers, including Mr Wildsmith, who was the Global Managing Director of Sable37.
The agreement contained restraint of trade provisions restricting the sellers from operating or becoming involved in competing businesses for a period of up to seven years.
The restrictions extended across several international markets and were intended to protect the goodwill acquired by DXC Eclipse.
As part of the transaction, Mr Wildsmith also agreed to remain employed within the acquired business for at least 12 months following completion.
He ultimately remained for more than three years before resigning in July 2021.
Following his departure, Mr Wildsmith established a new software business, Will Thirty Three Pty Ltd, which provided services involving Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central.
DXC Eclipse considered that the new business competed with the operations it had acquired from Sable37.
It subsequently commenced proceedings seeking to enforce the restraint provisions and prevent Mr Wildsmith from operating the new business.
What Did the Court Decide?
The Supreme Court of New South Wales initially considered whether the activities undertaken by Mr Wildsmith breached the restraint provisions.
The Court found that the new business did not fall within the relevant contractual definition of a competing business.
It also concluded that the restraints were unreasonable in scope and could not be enforced in the circumstances.
DXC Eclipse appealed that decision.
On 16 May 2023, the New South Wales Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal.
Was the New Business Actually Competing?
An important issue was how the expression “Competing Business” should be interpreted under the acquisition agreement.
The agreement defined the acquired business by reference to particular Microsoft software products and related technologies.
Although Mr Wildsmith’s new business also provided Microsoft software solutions, it focused on products that were different from those supplied by Sable37 at the time of the acquisition.
The Court of Appeal found that the new business did not fall within the contractual definition of a competing business.
Importantly, the Court distinguished between businesses operating within the same general industry and businesses actually competing in the activities protected by the contractual restraint.
The fact that both businesses provided Microsoft software services did not necessarily mean that the restraint had been breached.
The Court considered that the contractual definition was directed towards protecting the business acquired by DXC Eclipse, rather than restricting competition across the broader Microsoft software market.
Was a Seven-Year Restraint Reasonable?
The Court also considered whether the restraint was reasonable for the protection of the goodwill acquired by DXC Eclipse.
Although the agreement imposed restrictions lasting up to seven years, the Court did not suggest that restraints of this duration are necessarily unenforceable.
Instead, the Court examined the extent of competition between the businesses and whether the restrictions were justified by the commercial interests acquired.
The Court found that the competition was limited and that DXC Eclipse had not established why a restraint lasting seven years was required to protect the goodwill it had purchased.
The limited extent of competition made it more difficult to justify the breadth and duration of the restraint.
Although the parties had acknowledged in the agreement that the restraints were reasonable, the Court found that this acknowledgement did not establish their enforceability.
The decision therefore highlights that the enforceability of a restraint depends not simply on its duration, but on whether its scope can be justified by reference to the goodwill being protected.
A purchaser who has paid substantial consideration for goodwill must still be able to demonstrate that the restrictions are no wider than reasonably necessary to protect the goodwill acquired.
What Does This Mean for Queensland Business Purchases?
Although DXC Eclipse v Wildsmith was decided in New South Wales, the decision provides useful guidance for businesses negotiating restraint of trade provisions in Queensland.
In Queensland, restraints of trade are principally governed by common law principles.
The general position at common law is that a restraint of trade is unenforceable unless the party seeking to enforce it establishes that the restriction is no wider than reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate commercial interest and is not contrary to public policy.
In the context of a business sale, this may include protecting the goodwill acquired by the purchaser and the customer relationships associated with that goodwill.
Courts generally take a more favourable approach to restraints negotiated as part of the sale of a business than restraints imposed solely in an employment relationship.
This is because a purchaser who has paid for the goodwill of a business has a legitimate interest in protecting the value of what has been acquired.
By comparison, an employment restraint must be directed towards protecting legitimate interests of the employer, such as confidential information or customer relationships, rather than merely preventing competition.
- Interest protectedThe goodwill acquired and the customer relationships associated with it
- Court’s approachGenerally more favourable, because the purchaser has paid for the goodwill
- Interest protectedLegitimate interests such as confidential information or customer relationships
- Court’s approachMust protect those interests, not merely prevent competition
Importantly, the legal framework in New South Wales differs because of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW).
That legislation permits courts, in certain circumstances, to enforce a restraint to the extent that it is not contrary to public policy.
Queensland differenceQueensland does not have equivalent general legislation allowing courts to rewrite an unreasonable restraint in order to make it enforceable.
Accordingly, the wording of restraint provisions in Queensland business purchase agreements requires particular care.
A Queensland Example: GBAR (Australia) Pty Ltd v Brown
The Queensland Supreme Court considered similar principles in GBAR (Australia) Pty Ltd v Brown [2020] QSC 14.
The case concerned the sale of an asbestos removal business operated by Brown & Cremin Pty Ltd to GBAR (Australia) Pty Ltd.
The agreed purchase price was approximately $2.45 million, of which more than $2.1 million was attributed to goodwill.
Mr Brown was a director and shareholder of the selling company and had developed substantial customer relationships through his personal experience and reputation in the asbestos removal industry.
The business sale agreement contained a three-year restraint preventing the selling company from being involved in a similar business within Queensland.
Following the acquisition, Mr Brown remained involved in the business under an employment agreement.
A later settlement agreement imposed further restraints on Mr Brown following his departure, including an Australia-wide restraint with alternative periods of three years, two years or one year.
The dispute arose after the former selling company recommenced operating an asbestos removal business.
What Did the Queensland Supreme Court Decide?
The Court found that the restraint contained in the original business sale agreement was broader than reasonably necessary to protect the goodwill acquired by GBAR and was therefore unenforceable.
Importantly, Mr Brown was not personally a party to the business sale agreement, despite being a director and shareholder of the selling company.
The agreement required the corporate seller to obtain restraint covenants from its directors and shareholders. However, there was no evidence establishing whether the relevant covenant had been obtained.
The Court confirmed that the restraint contained in the business sale agreement could not operate directly against Mr Brown.
The Court also considered the restraints arising under Mr Brown’s employment and subsequent settlement arrangements.
The non-competition restraint in the employment agreement had been superseded by the later settlement agreement. The Court therefore did not need to finally determine whether that earlier employment restraint was reasonable.
Was the Australia-Wide Restraint Enforceable?
The subsequent settlement agreement imposed a restraint preventing Mr Brown from being involved in a competing business anywhere in Australia.
The Court found that the geographical scope of the restriction was excessive, particularly given that Mr Brown’s customer relationships were predominantly concentrated in South-East Queensland.
The restraint would have prevented him from working in his established industry across Australia, including in areas where he had not developed relevant customer relationships.
The Court concluded that the restraint was unenforceable.
Importantly, although the settlement agreement formed part of a broader commercial relationship, the Court assessed the restraint primarily by reference to employment principles.
By the time the settlement agreement was entered into, the goodwill had already been acquired by GBAR, and the agreement principally concerned the termination of Mr Brown’s employment.
The decision demonstrates that restraints entered into following a business sale are not automatically treated as business-sale restraints.
It also highlights the importance of ensuring that individuals whose personal reputation or customer relationships contribute significantly to a business’s goodwill are appropriately bound by contractual restrictions.
How Should Restraint of Trade Clauses Be Drafted?
When preparing a business purchase agreement, the restraint provisions should be carefully tailored to the nature of the business and the goodwill being acquired.
The agreement should clearly identify the business activities being restricted and the geographical area within which the restriction will apply.
For example, where a purchaser acquires a dental practice on the Gold Coast, it may seek to prevent the seller from establishing a competing practice within a specified geographical area.
The agreement may also restrict the seller from soliciting the practice’s existing patients or employees.
However, the scope of those restrictions should reflect the circumstances of the acquisition.
A restraint that is unnecessarily broad may be difficult to enforce, particularly where it prevents the seller from undertaking activities that do not genuinely threaten the goodwill sold.
Duration and Geographical Restrictions
The duration of a restraint should reflect the period reasonably required to protect the goodwill acquired by the purchaser.
A purchaser should not assume that a longer restraint is justified simply because a substantial purchase price has been paid.
Similarly, geographical restrictions should reflect the markets in which the acquired business operates and the extent of its customer relationships.
For example, a restraint covering the whole of Queensland may be difficult to justify where a Gold Coast dental practice primarily serves patients within a limited local area.
However, a broader geographical restriction may be appropriate where the acquired business has an established customer base across multiple regions.
A similar issue arose in GBAR v Brown, where the Court considered an Australia-wide restraint against the former principal of an asbestos removal business.
The Court found that the restriction extended beyond the areas in which Mr Brown had worked and developed customer relationships.
This demonstrates why geographical restraints should be supported by the actual operations of the acquired business rather than a purchaser’s broader commercial ambitions.
Cascading Restraint Provisions
Commercial agreements sometimes include cascading restraint provisions, which establish alternative geographical areas or restraint periods.
These provisions are intended to preserve an enforceable restriction where a broader restriction is found to be unreasonable.
For example, an agreement may provide for alternative restraint periods of five years, three years or one year.
Example of cascading restraint periods
Each alternative should be drafted as a separate and independent covenant, with appropriate provisions confirming that an unenforceable restriction may be severed without affecting the remaining restrictions.
This approach may allow a court to enforce an alternative restraint that is reasonable in the circumstances, even where a broader restriction cannot be enforced.
However, including cascading provisions does not automatically make an otherwise unreasonable restraint enforceable.
In Queensland, whether a narrower alternative can be enforced will depend on the drafting of the provision and the applicable common law principles.
Courts cannot simply rewrite an unreasonable restraint to make it reasonable.
For this reason, cascading provisions should be carefully prepared rather than treated as a substitute for establishing reasonable restrictions from the outset.
Who Should Be Bound by the Restraint?
Another important consideration is identifying the parties who should be bound by the restraint.
Where a business is sold by a company, the purchaser should consider whether the company’s directors or principals should also be personally bound.
This is particularly important where the goodwill of a business is closely associated with an individual who maintains strong customer relationships.
A restraint imposed only on the selling company may provide limited protection if the individual responsible for generating much of the business’s goodwill is free to establish a competing operation.
The decision in GBAR v Brown demonstrates the importance of this distinction.
Although Mr Brown was closely associated with the business being sold, he was not personally bound by the restraint in the business sale agreement.
The agreement should therefore identify the relevant parties and clearly establish their post-completion obligations.
What If the Seller Remains Involved After Completion?
Another important consideration arises where the seller agrees to remain with the business following the acquisition.
This is common where the purchaser requires assistance transitioning customer relationships or maintaining the business’s operations.
In these circumstances, the parties should consider how the restraint provisions in the business purchase agreement interact with any separate employment or consultancy agreement.
In DXC Eclipse, Mr Wildsmith was required to remain employed for a minimum period of 12 months but ultimately remained for more than three years.
The Court considered the relationship between the restraint imposed under the acquisition agreement and the shorter restraint contained in his employment arrangements.
The minimum 12-month employment requirement was relevant to assessing the period considered necessary to secure the benefit of the acquired goodwill.
Mr Wildsmith’s extended employment also gave DXC Eclipse a substantial opportunity to consolidate the business’s customer relationships.
Although the reasonableness of a restraint is assessed by reference to the circumstances when the agreement was entered into, subsequent circumstances may also be relevant when deciding whether to grant an injunction.
In this case, Mr Wildsmith’s extended employment was an additional consideration against granting injunctive relief.
The decision demonstrates why post-completion arrangements should be considered together rather than negotiated independently.
Where a business seller remains involved in the acquired business, the various contractual obligations should be consistent with the commercial objectives of the transaction.
Restraint of trade drafting checklist0 of 7 checked
All covered. Have the restraint reviewed before the agreement is signed.
What Can Business Purchasers Learn from These Decisions?
The decisions in DXC Eclipse and GBAR demonstrate that restraint of trade provisions must be carefully tailored to the circumstances of the business acquisition.
The two cases at a glance
DXC Eclipse Pty Ltd v Wildsmith [2023] NSWCA 98
- Business
- Sable37, Microsoft software solutions, acquired in 2018
- Restraint
- Up to seven years across several international markets
- Issue
- Did the seller’s new software business compete, and was the restraint reasonable?
- Outcome
- Not a competing business and the restraint was unreasonable; appeal dismissed on 16 May 2023
GBAR (Australia) Pty Ltd v Brown [2020] QSC 14
- Business
- Asbestos removal, about $2.45 million, with over $2.1 million for goodwill
- Restraint
- Three years in Queensland on the sale, then Australia-wide on settlement
- Issue
- Were the restraints reasonable, and was the key individual bound?
- Outcome
- Restraints too broad, and the sale restraint did not bind Mr Brown personally
In DXC Eclipse, the purchaser was unable to establish that the breadth and duration of the restraint were justified by the goodwill acquired.
In GBAR, the purchaser encountered difficulties because the contractual restrictions were too broad and the key individual associated with the business’s goodwill was not personally bound by the business sale restraint.
For purchasers, the objective should be to identify the goodwill being acquired and ensure that the contractual restrictions provide appropriate protection.
For sellers, it is equally important to understand the extent to which the proposed restraints may affect their future business activities.
Carefully drafted restraints can provide valuable protection, but their enforceability ultimately depends on the circumstances of the transaction.
Key takeawayUltimately, a restraint of trade should protect the goodwill being purchased, rather than simply prevent the seller from engaging in future competition.
How Vojdani Lawyers Can Assist
Vojdani Lawyers advises purchasers and sellers on business acquisitions throughout Queensland.
Our commercial lawyers assist with preparing and negotiating business purchase agreements, including restraint of trade provisions and contractual protections relating to goodwill.
We also advise on post-completion arrangements and contractual obligations arising from the sale of a business.
Our approach focuses on ensuring that the agreement appropriately protects our client’s interests while reflecting the commercial objectives of the transaction.
Contact Vojdani Lawyers for advice on buying or selling a business in Queensland.
Related reading
Keep reading
Article · 7 Sept 2026Buying or Selling a Business in Queensland: A $1.5 Million Lesson on Financial Disclosures and WarrantiesSellers who supplied financial statements omitting $572,000 of liabilities were ordered to pay over $1.5…Read article →
Article · 3 Sept 2026Buying or Selling a Company? Why a Share Sale Agreement MattersWhat buyers and sellers of company shares need to know: share sale versus asset sale, existing liabilities,…Read article →

