Vojdani Lawyers
Vojdani Lawyers

Vojdani Lawyers

Buying or Selling a Business in Queensland: A $1.5 Million Lesson on Financial Disclosures and Warranties

Person reviewing financial documents with a calculator and laptop

Quick answerIn Davis v Perry O’Brien Engineering, sellers of an earthmoving business provided financial statements that left out about $571,967 of liabilities. The Court of Appeal upheld damages of $1,526,798 for breach of warranty and misleading conduct. Accurate disclosure and well-drafted warranties are critical in a business sale.

Last reviewed: 3 November 2026

When purchasing an established business, understanding its financial position is essential to determining whether the proposed acquisition represents a sound investment.

Buyers commonly rely on financial statements and information provided by the seller when assessing the value of a business.

However, what happens when that information is inaccurate or important liabilities are not disclosed before completion?

The Queensland Court of Appeal decision in Davis v Perry O’Brien Engineering Pty Ltd [2025] QCA 18, delivered on 28 February 2025, highlights the significant consequences of providing misleading financial information during a business sale.

The decision also demonstrates the importance of carefully drafted warranties and continuing disclosure obligations in business purchase agreements.

Case at a glance

Purchasers succeedCourt of Appeal

Davis v Perry O’Brien Engineering Pty Ltd [2025] QCA 18

Court
Queensland Court of Appeal
Business
Shares in an earthmoving and civil contracting company
Price
About $5.34 million, reduced to $3.5 million after due diligence
Issue
Misleading financial statements and undisclosed liabilities
Outcome
$1,526,798 in damages plus interest; appeal dismissed on 28 February 2025

Background to the Dispute

The dispute concerned the sale of shares in a company operating an earthmoving and civil contracting business in Queensland.

In October 2015, the sellers entered into a share sale agreement with the purchasers for an initial purchase price of approximately $5.34 million.

The agreement included a due diligence period and a finance condition.

During the due diligence process, the purchasers raised concerns about the profitability of the business.

Following negotiations, the parties agreed to reduce the purchase price to $3.5 million.

Importantly, the agreement contained warranties requiring the sellers to ensure that financial information provided to the purchasers was accurate and not materially misleading.

The sellers were also required to disclose matters that could materially affect the profitability or value of the business before completion.

What Went Wrong?

In November 2015, the sellers provided financial statements showing that the company had recorded a net profit of approximately $70,670 for the four months ending 31 October 2015.

However, those financial statements did not account for outstanding creditor invoices totalling approximately $571,967, excluding GST.

Had those liabilities been properly recorded, the statements would have shown a net loss of approximately $500,000 rather than a profit.

What the accounts showed, and what they missed

$70,670Net profit reported for the four months to 31 October 2015
$571,967Creditor invoices left out of the statements, excluding GST
About $500,000Net loss the statements would have shown

The financial information was also provided to the purchasers’ proposed financier, Westpac, as part of the finance approval process.

On 18 November 2015, Westpac provided conditional finance approval, which required the sellers to sign a letter confirming that the financial statements accurately reflected the company’s financial position.

On 23 November 2015, the sellers signed that letter, referred to in the proceedings as the “Westpac letter”, despite knowing that the financial statements were inaccurate.

The purchasers relied on the Westpac letter in seeking finance and ultimately proceeding with the acquisition.

Further financial information provided during the transaction also failed to disclose significant liabilities.

The purchasers proceeded with the acquisition, completing the share transfer on 23 December 2015.

It was only after completion that the purchasers became aware of the extent of the inaccuracies.

How the transaction unfolded

  1. October 2015Share sale agreement signed at about $5.34 million
  2. After due diligencePrice reduced to $3.5 million
  3. 18 November 2015Westpac gives conditional finance approval
  4. 23 November 2015Sellers sign the “Westpac letter” despite knowing the statements were inaccurate
  5. 23 December 2015Share transfer completed
  6. 28 February 2025Court of Appeal dismisses the sellers’ appeal

The dispute subsequently proceeded to the Supreme Court of Queensland.

What Did the Court Decide?

The Supreme Court found that the sellers had breached their contractual warranties and engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct contrary to section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law.

The purchasers were also entitled to compensation under section 236 of the Australian Consumer Law for loss suffered as a result of that conduct.

The Court concluded that the financial information provided by the sellers had materially misrepresented the company’s financial position.

Importantly, the Court found that the purchasers would not have proceeded with the transaction had the true financial circumstances been disclosed.

Why Was the Finance Condition Important?

An important aspect of the decision concerned the financing arrangements for the acquisition.

The purchasers required substantial bank finance to complete the purchase.

The financial statements and the Westpac letter were therefore important not only to the purchasers but also to the lender assessing the transaction.

The Court considered the likelihood that Westpac would have declined to finance the acquisition had the company’s true financial position been disclosed.

In those circumstances, it was likely that the due diligence or finance condition would not have been satisfied and the transaction would not have proceeded.

This was significant because the sellers argued that, had the purchasers received accurate financial information, they would simply have negotiated a further adjustment to the purchase price.

The Court rejected that argument, finding that the evidence supported the conclusion that the transaction would not have completed in the absence of the misleading conduct.

How Were Damages Assessed?

The Supreme Court awarded damages of $1,526,798, together with interest, in favour of the purchasers.

The sellers appealed, challenging the assessment of damages and the conclusions concerning the effect of the misleading information.

On 28 February 2025, the Queensland Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal.

The Court upheld the finding that the purchasers would not have completed the acquisition had they received accurate financial information.

It also upheld the approach to assessing damages, which reflected the difference between the amount paid by the purchasers, including associated liabilities discharged at completion, and the actual value of the shares acquired, subject to the relevant adjustments.

The decision demonstrates that the financial consequences of misleading conduct may extend beyond the amount of any undisclosed liability.

Why Are Seller Warranties Important?

A business purchase agreement will often contain warranties concerning the financial position of the business and the accuracy of information provided to the purchaser.

These warranties are contractual promises made by the seller and may provide the purchaser with remedies if the information proves incorrect.

In Davis v Perry O’Brien Engineering, the share sale agreement required the sellers to ensure that the information supplied to the purchasers was accurate and that material information had not been withheld.

The agreement also imposed continuing obligations requiring the sellers to notify the purchasers of matters that could materially affect the business before completion.

These provisions became central to the dispute.

Although the purchasers had undertaken due diligence and negotiated a reduction in the purchase price, the sellers remained responsible for complying with their contractual warranties.

Key takeawayImportantly, the purchasers’ satisfaction of the due diligence condition did not relieve the sellers of their continuing disclosure obligations.

The decision reinforces the importance of carefully considering the warranties included in a business purchase agreement and ensuring that they remain appropriate throughout the transaction.

What Does This Mean for Business Purchasers?

For purchasers, the decision highlights why due diligence should extend beyond a review of historical financial statements.

It is important to investigate the business’s outstanding liabilities and assess whether the financial information provided accurately reflects its trading position.

Where a purchase involves acquiring shares in a company, the purchaser also acquires ownership of an entity that may have existing liabilities.

This differs from an asset purchase, where the purchaser generally acquires specified business assets rather than ownership of the company itself.

The distinction can significantly affect the level of due diligence required and the contractual protections negotiated.

Purchasers should also consider whether the business purchase agreement contains appropriate warranties and indemnities to address the risks identified.

Where financial information changes between signing and completion, updated information may be required to ensure that the transaction proceeds on an informed basis.

What Does This Mean for Business Sellers?

For sellers, the decision demonstrates the importance of ensuring that information supplied during a business sale is accurate and complete.

Financial representations made during negotiations may have significant legal consequences, particularly where the purchaser relies on those representations when determining the purchase price.

Sellers should also understand the warranties and disclosure obligations contained in the sale agreement before signing.

In some circumstances, these obligations continue until completion and require the seller to disclose material changes affecting the business.

The decision highlights that a seller may face substantial liability even after a transaction has completed.

Careful preparation of financial records and appropriate legal advice can help ensure that the contractual arrangements accurately reflect the agreed commercial position.

The Importance of Due Diligence and Contractual Protections

The decision in Davis v Perry O’Brien Engineering provides an important reminder that due diligence and contractual warranties serve different purposes.

Due diligence allows purchasers to investigate the financial position and legal obligations of the business before proceeding.

Contractual warranties provide additional protection by requiring the seller to stand behind particular representations or disclosed information.

  • PurposeAllows the purchaser to investigate the financial position and legal obligations of the business
  • WhenBefore the purchaser proceeds
  • PurposeRequire the seller to stand behind particular representations or disclosed information
  • WhenCan continue to apply until completion, and claims may arise afterwards

Both are important when structuring a business acquisition.

For purchasers, the objective is to understand the risks associated with the acquisition and negotiate appropriate contractual protections.

For sellers, the objective is to ensure that the information provided is accurate and that the agreed warranties appropriately reflect the circumstances of the business.

The decision demonstrates how carefully prepared contractual arrangements can become critical when disputes arise after completion.

How Vojdani Lawyers Can Assist

Vojdani Lawyers advises purchasers and sellers on business acquisitions throughout Queensland.

Our commercial lawyers assist with business purchase agreements and share sale transactions, including due diligence investigations and the negotiation of contractual warranties.

We work with clients to identify potential risks and ensure that their contractual arrangements reflect the commercial objectives of the transaction.

Contact Vojdani Lawyers for advice on buying or selling a business in Queensland.